Rootwurks Blog

Zero Sugar” Class Action Lawsuits Show the Importance of Staying Updated on Product Labelling Requirements

Written by Ben Hartman | Nov 19, 2026, 9:28:19 PM

Could a “Zero Added Sugar” claim have your company facing a class-action lawsuit?

In a lawsuit filed on November 5th in federal court, Plaintiff Angela Saban alleged that Yoplait violated state statutes and common law doctrines by misrepresenting the products as having “0g added sugar,” when they actually contained allulose, a natural sweetener used as an alternative to sugar.

“Defendant’s own labeling admits the products contain allulose, a sugar,” the lawsuit states, adding that the products “therefore, cannot be classified as 0g added sugar, as claimed on the products' packaging and advertising.”

The lawsuit is not without precedent. More than a decade ago, Yoplait parent company General Mills agreed to pay $8.5 million in February 2013 to settle a series of lawsuits alleging that they made deceptive claims about the gut health benefits of its “Yo-Plus” brand yogurt.

In July, the U.S. The Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that consumers can try to show Chobani violated state consumer protection laws because its "Zero Sugar" yogurt contained four grams per serving of allulose. Under federal regulations, foods that are advertised as sugar-free must contain less than half a gram of sugar.

Earlier this week, FoodDive wrote that “consumer awareness of ultraprocessed foods and functional ingredients is quickly expanding and creating new legal risks for companies.”

In 2020, the FDA announced that its "enforcement discretion” guidance would apply to allulose and the need to list it under “total sugars” or “added sugars” on Nutrition Facts labels. This made listing allulose under sugars on labeling a voluntary decision by consumers - but not one without risk due to the FDA’s assertion that allulose is a monosaccharide and thus defined as a sugar under current regulations.

As Eurofins wrote in October, “as a result, manufacturers may find themselves navigating two realities simultaneously: one framework for Nutrition Facts labeling and another for evaluating the potential risk associated with front-of-package claims such as ‘sugar free’ or ‘zero sugar.’

In other words, companies will not face agency enforcement actions from the FDA, but they can still expose themselves to consumer litigation due to how they label products that contain allulose.

The Wave of Copycat lawsuits

The appealate court’s decision in the Chobani case opened the door for a wave of lawsuits. The ruling confirmed that the FDA’s enforcement discretion guidelines don’t shield companies from state consumer protection laws, meaning more brands are likely to find themselves facing lawsuits over how they label allulose.

In lawsuits such as those against Yoplait, or brands like Liquid Death and KIND, plaintiffs can reasonably argue that “zero sugar” should indicate a total absence of sugar even if allulose isn’t metabolized by the body in the same way as table sugar.

This is further bolstered because many of these products carry a “price premium” tied directly to their “zero sugar” claims.

Being Reasonable about "Reasonable Consumers"

These lawsuits deal heavily with the legal concept of the “reasonable consumer” standard. They ask: Would a reasonable consumer assume that “zero sugar” means no sugar whatsoever? And would this reasonable consumer feel they were misled if the product contained allulose?

Even if the label adheres to FDA Nutrition Facts requirements, the reasonable consumer still may be able to credibly argue they were misled.

Protect Your Brand

Simply put, the barrier to entry for these lawsuits is very low.

To protect their brands, companies should examine their product lines to identify any that use allulose and see if the products fall under the 0.5g of sugar per serving threshold. They should examine any sugar-related claims they make on packaging or marketing and not simply rely on the fact that they are FDA-compliant to shield them from litigation.